An Original Policy and Practice Article about Scholarly Publishing Economics, Qualitative Infrastructure Studies & Open Science Policy
Nash Ang | OBRA Incorporated | Metro Manila, Philippines
0009-0001-7920-4027 | [email protected]
Abstract
Every academic year, Philippine state universities and colleges approve tens of thousands of theses, dissertations, and faculty research studies addressing local agriculture, public health, disaster resilience, and provincial governance. The overwhelming majority of this intellectual output never reaches global citation indexes. It remains trapped on physical library shelves, stored on deteriorating optical media, or uploaded as unindexed PDF attachments to institutional websites with expiring domains. In 2021, the Commission on Higher Education mandated that all higher education institutions transition toward digital library systems and open access repositories. The mandate, however, arrived without dedicated funding streams, technical staffing provisions, or procurement pathways adapted for recurring digital services. This paper examines how five interlocking structural conditions spanning physical infrastructure vulnerability, labor precarity in academic libraries, grant-cycle dependency, statutory procurement constraints under Republic Act No. 12009, and persistent identifier costs denominated in foreign currencies interact to produce the systematic failure of digital scholarly preservation across Philippine public higher education. Drawing on the diagnostic tradition that preceded the establishment of SciELO in Latin America and Redalyc in Mexico, and engaging with the scholar-led publishing movement's arguments for collectively governed infrastructure, the paper reasons from this diagnosis toward a propositional framework: the institutional design principles that a sustainable Diamond Open Access consortium would need to embody in order to operate within the regulatory, fiscal, and environmental realities of Southeast Asian public universities.
Keywords: Diamond Open Access, institutional repositories, scholarly publishing economics, Global South, persistent identifiers, public procurement, university consortia
Key points:
Institutional repository abandonment across resource-constrained universities is driven by structural mismatches in public procurement law, foreign-currency fees, and labor precarity rather than individual staff technical shortcomings.
Relying on US-dollar-denominated persistent identifier services creates recurring currency risks for public institutions in the Global South, where non-commercial alternatives like Archival Resource Keys offer zero-cost persistent identification stability.
Sustainable Diamond Open Access in developing higher education systems requires embedding recurring infrastructure costs within existing domestic statutory procurement thresholds like Small Value Procurement under Republic Act No. 12009.
Shared consortial entities that separate long-term data preservation from mobile-first public reading interfaces relieve isolated campus libraries of unmanageable technical maintenance overheads.
In 2021, the Philippine Commission on Higher Education issued Memorandum Order No. 22, establishing minimum requirements for academic libraries across all higher education institutions in the country. Among its provisions, the order mandated that universities transition their collections, services, and information systems toward digital platforms, electronic databases, and open access repositories (CHED 2021). The memorandum arrived during the tail end of a pandemic that had already forced campuses into emergency remote learning, and it reflected a genuine national need. Philippine state universities and colleges produce a substantial volume of applied research each year. Undergraduate capstone projects in teacher education, criminal justice, business administration, and agricultural science accumulate in the thousands across the 114 chartered state universities alone. Graduate theses and faculty publications add further layers. Yet the vast majority of this scholarly output remains invisible to the global academic community, prevented from generating broader collective benefit by the absence of sustainable digital infrastructure capable of preserving and indexing regional scholarship.
The disconnect between regulatory ambition and institutional capacity defines the central tension this paper addresses. CHED Memorandum Order No. 22 told universities to build digital repositories, but it did not provide the funding to host them, the technical staff to maintain them, or the procurement mechanisms to pay for recurring digital services within the constraints of Philippine public expenditure law. The result is a national landscape littered with institutional repositories in various stages of abandonment: DSpace installations that went offline when the librarian who configured them transferred to another campus; digital collections funded by pandemic-era grants that lost their hosting when the grant cycle ended; university websites advertising repository URLs that return nothing but error pages.
This pattern of repository failure is not unique to the Philippines, but the Philippine case concentrates a set of structural pressures with particular clarity. Provincial state universities occupy physical environments hostile to on-premises computing: typhoon corridors, monsoon flood zones, and island provinces served by unstable electrical grids. Academic library staffing in regional campuses is severely constrained, with digital curation responsibilities routinely assigned to cataloging librarians who carry full reference and circulation workloads without dedicated systems engineering support. Public university expenditures are governed by Republic Act No. 12009, the New Government Procurement Act, whose institutional routines remain optimized for physical goods rather than recurring digital subscriptions. At the same time, fee-bearing persistent identifier services that support global scholarly discoverability, principally the Crossref network, require annual organizational dues denominated in US dollars, creating a form of recurring foreign-currency debt exposure that state colleges budgeting exclusively in Philippine pesos cannot reliably sustain.
This paper examines how these structural conditions interact to produce systematic repository failure, and it reasons from that diagnosis toward a propositional framework for what a sustainable alternative would require. The research question guiding the analysis is twofold: How do the intersecting conditions of physical infrastructure vulnerability, library labor precarity, grant-cycle dependency, statutory procurement barriers, and persistent identifier costs denominated in foreign currencies produce the systematic failure of digital scholarly preservation across Philippine state universities? And what alternative institutional arrangements could sustainably resolve these failures?
The paper follows a diagnostic tradition that has precedent in the Global South. In the mid-1990s, documentation of regional research disparities showed that rigorous scholarship from developing nations remained largely excluded from commercial citation networks, creating an artificial condition of lost science that denied regional researchers epistemic justice (Gibbs 1995). In response to this exclusion, Latin American information scientists formulated alternative dissemination models, establishing the operational groundwork that preceded the launch of SciELO in Brazil (Packer et al. 1998). Similarly, in formulating the institutional framework for Redalyc following its 2002 launch at the Autonomous University of the State of Mexico, critical analyses argued that scholarly knowledge in the region had to be organized as a digital commons sustained through collective institutional investment rather than mediated by commercial publishers (Aguado-López et al. 2003). Following this diagnostic tradition, foundational institutional studies establish the structural criteria required before technical platform development can succeed. This paper provides that corresponding institutional diagnosis for the Philippines and, by extension, for Southeast Asia.
The following section examines the structural conditions that produce repository failure across Philippine state universities. From that diagnostic analysis, the third section develops the institutional design principles that a sustainable Diamond Open Access consortium would need to embody, drawing on the scholar-led publishing movement, the public utility doctrine articulated by the Knowledge Futures Group, and the non-commercial persistent identifier systems maintained by research libraries in the United States. The final section outlines the broader institutional implications of this model for campus administrators, national higher education regulators, and international scholars examining Diamond Open Access sustainability across the Global South.
The failure of institutional repositories across Philippine state universities is routinely attributed to insufficient administrative commitment or technological illiteracy among campus personnel. These explanations locate the problem within individual institutions and imply that the solution lies in better training or stronger leadership. The analysis offered here rejects that framing. Drawing on the tradition of infrastructure studies introduced by Star and Ruhleder (1996), who argued that infrastructure is a relational property revealed most clearly at the moment of breakdown, this section treats repository failure not as a local administrative shortcoming but as the direct consequence of structural conditions operating at the intersection of geography, labor, public finance, and global publishing economics.
The physical environment is the most immediate of these conditions, and the one most consistently overlooked in scholarly communication literature produced from temperate, electrified, well-connected research universities in the Global North. Philippine state universities are distributed across an archipelago of over 7,600 islands spanning three major island groups. Provincial campuses in the Visayas and Mindanao frequently occupy sites served by cooperative electrical grids that experience scheduled rotating brownouts during dry seasons and unscheduled outages during the typhoon months that dominate the second half of every calendar year. The Philippines sits at the western edge of the Pacific typhoon belt and experiences an average of twenty tropical cyclones annually, several of which make direct landfall with destructive force (PAGASA 2023). In this environment, on-premises server hardware housed in administrative offices or library storage rooms lacking dedicated climate control, uninterruptible power supplies, or raised flooring faces cumulative thermal stress, moisture intrusion, and power surge damage that commercially maintained data centers are designed to prevent.
Because environmental hazards degrade hardware quietly over time, institutional awareness of infrastructure follows the pattern identified by Star and Ruhleder (1996), remaining unobserved during routine operation and surfacing only at the threshold of failure. In Philippine state universities, this breakdown becomes visible when a repository URL stops resolving, when accreditation evaluators inspect digital holdings and find an empty database, or when a faculty member discovers that a deposited thesis vanished alongside an unbacked storage drive. Between those moments of acute crisis, digital preservation operates in institutional invisibility, sustained or abandoned by a single staff member whose maintenance labor remains unacknowledged in campus budget allocations.
That staff member is typically a librarian. The labor conditions under which Philippine academic librarians operate are another major structural pressure producing repository failure. Documenting the condition of digital initiatives across Philippine academic libraries, Lagas II and Isip (2023) showed that provincial campuses frequently operate with acute staffing shortages, where a single professional librarian must manage cataloging, reference services, circulation, and institutional digitization simultaneously without systems engineering support. When a campus administration decides to implement an institutional repository, often in response to accreditation requirements or the availability of a short-term development grant, the maintenance of the repository's technical infrastructure is added to this existing workload. The librarian learns to install DSpace on a Linux server, configure metadata schemas, manage user permissions, and troubleshoot search indexing errors, acquiring technical skills that fall well outside conventional library science training.
The vulnerability of this arrangement lies in its dependence on a single person. When the librarian who acquired these technical skills transfers to another institution, accepts a position in the private sector, or retires, the repository loses not merely a staff member but all of its institutional technical knowledge. No documentation exists for the server configuration because the librarian never had time to write any. No replacement has been trained because there was no second staff member to train. The DSpace installation continues to run on its original version until a security vulnerability is exploited, the database index corrupts, or the operating system reaches end-of-life support. The repository does not crash dramatically; it decays silently, responding to fewer and fewer queries until someone notices that it no longer responds at all.
The operational exhaustion of self-hosted publishing infrastructure extends beyond resource-constrained environments, as documented by practitioner accounts from the Global North (Pooley 2022). In establishing the scholar-led non-profit press mediastudies.press, Pooley initially operated self-hosted open-source platforms on independent cloud servers. Despite having dedicated institutional backing and reliable infrastructure, Pooley found the technical maintenance burden unsustainable. The constant demands of security patching, platform upgrades, and server administration pulled him away from primary editorial work, prompting a transition to managed infrastructure. Pooley's experience provides an instructive illustrative comparison: if an independent scholar-publisher in a well-resourced academic environment found the self-maintenance of open-source publishing infrastructure unsustainable, the expectation that an isolated Filipino campus librarian could maintain similar systems indefinitely, while managing full cataloging workloads on an unstable electrical grid, is a structural impossibility.
A related pressure is fiscal, operating through the dependency of repository initiatives on short-term external funding. A significant number of institutional repositories across Philippine state universities were established during the pandemic, when emergency remote learning encouraged short-term digital projects funded by temporary grants that lacked ongoing operational support (Lagas II and Isip 2023). Others were built through time-limited projects funded by the Department of Science and Technology, the Commission on Higher Education's research development grants, or international aid agencies. In each case, the initial funding covered hardware purchases, software installation, and training workshops: the visible, countable deliverables that grant reports require. What the grants did not cover, and what no short-term grant can cover, are the recurring operational costs that sustain a digital repository over time: annual domain registration, cloud hosting fees, software license renewals, security certificate management, and the ongoing labor of metadata curation and system maintenance.
When the grant cycle concludes, these recurring costs have no dedicated budget line to absorb them. The university's General Appropriations Act allocation prioritizes direct instruction, enrollment-driven expenditures, and physical plant maintenance. While national accounting rules accommodate subscription expenses broadly, campus-level budget officers rarely allocate recurring operating funds to digital repository hosting after external grants end. Creating a dedicated internal budget line requires administrative justifications that provincial campus accountants are seldom positioned to advance. The repository, originally celebrated in the grant's final report as a successful capacity-building outcome, becomes an unfunded liability.
At the regulatory level, digital service economics intersects directly with Philippine public procurement law. Republic Act No. 12009, the New Government Procurement Act of 2024, governs expenditures across public agencies and chartered state universities and colleges (Republic of the Philippines 2024). Enacted to replace the older framework of Republic Act No. 9184, the statute was designed to ensure fiscal integrity by requiring competitive public bidding for major capital acquisitions. For routine operational requirements, the law retains a streamlined alternative modality designated as Small Value Procurement, allowing public institutions to obtain goods and services up to two million Philippine pesos through direct quotations without navigating months of formal bidding.
The challenge for digital repository maintenance is that critical services, particularly cloud hosting from international providers and persistent identifier memberships from organizations headquartered abroad, are billed in foreign currencies. Paying a US-dollar invoice through a state university's disbursement system requires foreign currency conversion, documentation of exchange rates, and rigorous compliance with Commission on Audit guidelines for overseas disbursements. This administrative workflow routinely takes weeks or months, depending on the availability of funds in the university's trust accounts and the scheduling of bank wire transfers. During the gap between invoice receipt and final remittance, services lapse. Hosting accounts expire. Domain registrations fail to renew. The repository goes offline not because anyone decided to shut it down, but because the bureaucratic machinery required to disburse a seventy-dollar annual invoice could not complete its cycle before the payment deadline.
A final structural condition concerns the economics of persistent identifiers: the stable, globally resolvable links that connect a deposited research output to its citation record across scholarly databases worldwide. The Crossref network, which administers the Digital Object Identifier system used by the majority of internationally indexed journals and repositories, requires participating organizations to pay an annual membership fee plus per-deposit charges (Crossref 2024). For large research universities in the Global North, these costs are marginal, absorbed into library budgets that already run into the millions of dollars annually. For a provincial Philippine state college whose entire library operational budget may not exceed two million pesos in a given fiscal year, Crossref's annual membership fee, denominated in US dollars and subject to currency fluctuation, represents a qualitatively different kind of financial exposure.
When the Philippine peso depreciates against the dollar, as it did significantly during the global inflationary period of 2022 to 2023, the real cost of maintaining a Crossref membership rises without any corresponding increase in the university's peso-denominated budget. To alleviate international financial disparities, Crossref operates the Global Equitable Membership program, which waives annual fees for institutions in the least economically-advantaged countries. Eligibility, however, is restricted to low-income economies under World Bank International Development Association criteria. Lower-middle-income countries such as the Philippines remain ineligible for these waivers, leaving their state universities exposed to dollar-denominated dues without institutional relief.
When annual budget releases from the Department of Budget and Management are delayed during the first quarter of each fiscal year, institutional accounts fall into arrears. While Crossref preserves persistent resolution for existing DOIs after an account lapses, an organization in arrears cannot register new identifiers and cannot update existing metadata records. For an academic library managing a continuous flow of theses and faculty journals, this administrative suspension halts digital ingestion. Over time, as campus servers migrate or institutional web paths change, an institution unable to update its metadata suffers creeping link rot across its historical collection, leaving deposited scholarship unreachable not because research was retracted, but because an accounting office in a provincial capital could not execute an overseas wire transfer on time.
These five conditions do not operate in isolation. They interlock. A typhoon damages the campus power grid, corrupting the database of a self-hosted repository maintained by a single librarian who was already struggling to keep an outdated DSpace installation running on hardware purchased through a grant that ended two years ago, hosted on a domain whose registration lapsed because the accounting office could not process the dollar-denominated renewal in time. Each failure compounds the next. The result is not a single dramatic collapse but a slow, cumulative decay that renders entire institutional research collections invisible, not to the campus community, which knows the research exists in physical form, but to the global scholarly ecosystem that depends on digital discoverability to function.
The structural conditions documented in the preceding section are not arbitrary misfortunes. They are systemic consequences of a specific institutional arrangement: individual campuses bearing the full burden of digital infrastructure in an environment where physical, fiscal, labor, and regulatory conditions make that burden unsustainable. Any viable alternative must therefore address not merely an isolated symptom but the institutional model itself, translating this structural diagnosis into actionable design principles for collective infrastructure.
The most fundamental of these principles is collective stewardship rooted in data solidarity. If the structural weakness of the current arrangement is that isolated campuses maintain infrastructure alone, then the alternative must distribute infrastructure maintenance across a shared institutional body. The ScholarLed consortium in Europe, a network of scholar-led, non-profit open access presses including Open Book Publishers, Mattering Press, meson press, Open Humanities Press, and punctum books, has demonstrated one model of this approach, pooling advocacy, metadata standards, and infrastructure knowledge across independently governed presses that share a common commitment to non-commercial publishing (Adema and Moore 2018). The Knowledge Futures Group, established at MIT to develop and maintain PubPub as a community-governed publishing platform, articulated this rationale by framing scholarly communication systems as public utilities comparable to municipal water networks and electrical grids, requiring collective public maintenance rather than dependence on commercial markets (Rich 2020). Analyzing this transition, Pooley (2022) observed that managed community platforms relieve scholars of the unsustainable technical overhead associated with self-hosting, allowing editorial labor to remain focused on scholarship.
Extending this principle to Philippine public higher education requires an approach informed by design justice, directly confronting the material and statutory constraints that the European and North American scholar-led movements do not face. State universities in the Philippines cannot simply subscribe to international platforms or join international consortia without navigating Republic Act No. 12009. They cannot pay recurring invoices in foreign currencies without triggering procurement procedures designed for an entirely different category of expenditure. They cannot assign dedicated technical staff to infrastructure maintenance because they do not have dedicated technical staff to assign. The consortium model that emerges from these constraints must therefore be domestic in legal registration, peso-denominated in its financial structure, and designed to operate within the procurement thresholds that allow state universities to approve service agreements through their existing operational budgets.
Structuring this shared capacity requires an organizational vehicle adapted to the public sector. Rather than leaving each university to negotiate individual contracts with overseas service providers, a collective institutional body operates as a data cooperative, pooling service demand, managing vendor relationships, and providing shared technical oversight on behalf of its member campuses. By centralizing systems engineering, server monitoring, and software maintenance within a dedicated domestic non-profit entity, individual campuses are relieved of the unrealistic expectation that local library staff should independently operate large-scale digital publishing infrastructure.
A complementary design principle concerns the separation of preservation from dissemination. The dominant approach to institutional repository software in Philippine higher education has been the monolithic platform, typically DSpace or, less frequently, EPrints, that attempts to serve simultaneously as an archival preservation system, a metadata management tool, a public search interface, and a reading platform. This single-platform approach forces competing priorities into a single fragile database. The rigorous metadata standards and format migration protocols required for long-term digital preservation demand a different technical emphasis than the responsive typography, mobile accessibility, and community engagement features required for effective scholarly communication with diverse audiences.
The scholar-led publishing landscape has increasingly recognized this tension. The Simon Fraser University Mind the Gap project catalogued over fifty open-source scholarly publishing tools, documenting the rapid growth of specialized platforms for different functions: some designed for journal management, others for monograph production, others for data curation, others for public reading (Maxwell et al. 2019). Pooley's attempt to operate multiple independent publishing applications at the same time illustrates this fragmentation from the practitioner's perspective: specialized software exists for each discrete function, but no single campus can sustainably maintain such a combined system in isolation.
The design principle that emerges from this landscape is architectural pluralism: separating the preservation function from the dissemination function and assigning each to a platform purpose-built for it. A preservation layer would handle structured metadata, dataset curation, Dublin Core compliance, and automated harvesting through the Open Archives Initiative Protocol for Metadata Harvesting, ensuring that deposited research is discoverable by Google Scholar, BASE, OpenAIRE, and the ASEAN Citation Index. A dissemination layer would handle the human reading experience: responsive mobile typography that renders legibly on the smartphones through which the majority of Filipino students and faculty access the internet, multimedia embeds for audio-visual research outputs, community annotation, and iterative versioning that allows living documents to evolve through scholarly conversation rather than remaining frozen at the point of initial deposit. Existing open-source tools already support both functions independently. Harvard's Dataverse Project established the technical foundation for open-access research repositories (King 2007), evolving into a mature preservation platform with native support for structured datasets and standardized metadata export (Crosas 2011). Alongside it, PubPub, developed by the Knowledge Futures Group at MIT, provides a web-first reading platform designed explicitly for scholarly communication beyond the static PDF (Rich 2020). What is missing in Southeast Asia is not the software. It is the institutional arrangement to operate these tools collectively on behalf of universities that cannot maintain them alone.
Resolving the persistent identifier problem requires evaluating both non-commercial identifier systems and collective membership models. In commercial and non-profit journal publishing, organizations often manage identifier fees through Crossref's Sponsor program, which allows smaller publishers to join through an intermediary, or through national DataCite consortia that pool membership costs. For isolated provincial universities in the Philippines, however, neither option is readily accessible independently: establishing a direct sponsor relationship requires international coordination and recurring currency transfers that individual campus libraries cannot execute.
Archival Resource Keys offer a sovereign, zero-cost alternative. ARKs are persistent identifiers administered through a globally distributed network of naming authorities, with resolution handled by the Name-to-Thing resolver maintained by the California Digital Library at the University of California (Kunze and Bermès 2022). Unlike DOIs, ARKs impose no annual organizational membership fees and no per-identifier registration charges. Any organization can register as a naming authority and begin minting ARKs at no cost. The identifiers resolve globally through the same internet infrastructure that supports DOI resolution, and they can be embedded in citation contexts, metadata records, and scholarly databases. The California Digital Library, the Internet Archive, the Bibliothèque nationale de France, and the Smithsonian Institution all use ARKs for long-term identification.
The objection commonly raised against ARKs is that they lack the automatic metadata exchange infrastructure that Crossref provides for DOIs. While Crossref metadata exchange supports international journal indexing, this consideration is less pressing for public university repositories in the Global South, where the realistic alternative to ARKs is an account freeze or no persistent identifiers at all. A domestic consortium provides the ideal framework to bridge this gap: the consortium can mint ARKs for routine graduate theses and grey literature at zero ongoing cost, while selectively acting as a domestic Crossref Sponsor or DataCite member for flagship university journals, paying pooled fees through a single domestic entity in Philippine pesos.
Any consortium serving public universities must also align its financial structure with the procurement law governing those universities. This is not an afterthought or an administrative detail. It is a design constraint as fundamental as the choice of software platform or metadata schema. The closure of First Monday in May 2026, after thirty years of uninterrupted non-commercial publishing, illustrated the vulnerability of publishing infrastructure sustained by individual commitment rather than institutional embedding (Klang 2026). Edward Valauskas's extraordinary personal dedication kept the journal alive for three decades, but the model had no mechanism for surviving the departure of its founding steward. This vulnerability reflects broader empirical patterns across non-commercial scholarly publishing. In an extensive investigation of Diamond Open Access operational drivers, Yoon et al. (2024) established that institutional ownership and secure financial backing are decisive factors for long-term viability, concluding that sustainable non-commercial publishing requires coordinated administrative structures rather than reliance on individual volunteerism. For Diamond Open Access infrastructure to endure across generations, it must be embedded in the administrative and fiscal routines of the institutions it serves, not dependent on the exceptional energy of any individual champion.
In the Philippine context, this embedding means structuring the consortium as a domestic non-profit that issues official receipts, prices annual services in Philippine pesos within the two-million-peso Small Value Procurement ceiling established by Republic Act No. 12009, and works with university procurement offices through routine domestic accounting channels. The operational model is deliberately unglamorous: an annual sustaining contribution, processed through the same accounting workflow as a journal subscription renewal, that gives the participating university access to managed cloud infrastructure, professional metadata validation, persistent identifier registration, and automated compliance documentation for accreditation evaluators. No foreign currency. No international wire transfer. No protracted public bidding cycles. The administrative friction drops significantly, and the likelihood of sustained institutional participation rises accordingly.
This propositional framework operates within the broader international context of the Diamond Open Access movement. The UNESCO Recommendation on Open Science, adopted by 193 member states in November 2021, calls upon nations to prioritize non-commercial, community-governed scholarly infrastructure and to ensure that access to scientific knowledge is not restricted by financial barriers for either readers or authors (UNESCO 2021). The First Global Summit on Diamond Open Access in Toluca, Mexico, in 2023, and the Second Global Summit in Cape Town, South Africa, in December 2024, reinforced this agenda by bringing together institutional actors from Latin America, Africa, Europe, and Asia to map regional challenges and coordinate infrastructure development (Mounier and Rooryck 2024). The non-commercial publishing infrastructure established across Latin America shows that collective public investment can operate at national and regional scale across decades. SciELO coordinates a decentralized network of national journal collections supported through public research councils (Packer 2009), while Redalyc and AmeliCA sustain thousands of Diamond Open Access journals anchored directly in autonomous university funding (Aguado-López and Becerril-García 2019).
Yet the international conversation has offered limited concrete guidance on how developing countries should apply these principles within the specific constraints of their existing regulatory frameworks. The UNESCO Recommendation calls for adequate funding and sustainable infrastructure without specifying how a state university governed by procurement law designed for physical goods should pay for perpetual digital services. The Diamond OA Summits produced declarations of principle without procurement templates. The Latin American precedents are instructive but emerged within regulatory environments, such as Brazilian state funding agencies and Mexican autonomous university budgets, that are structurally different from the Philippine system of national appropriations, Commission on Audit oversight, and Republic Act No. 12009 compliance.
The Philippine case, precisely because of its regulatory specificity, offers a substantive contribution to this international conversation. If a consortium model can be designed to operate sustainably within the constraints of RA 12009, embedding Diamond Open Access within existing domestic administrative routines rather than requiring new national legislation or exceptional exemptions, it provides a workable model for other developing nations navigating comparable procurement barriers. Designing explicitly for a highly constrained regulatory environment advances decolonial computing in practice, producing resilient institutional models that can survive contact with the administrative and fiscal realities of resource-limited public universities across the Global South.
This paper has diagnosed five interlocking structural conditions that produce the systematic failure of digital scholarly preservation across Philippine state universities, and it has reasoned from that diagnosis toward the design principles that a sustainable Diamond Open Access consortium must embody. Interpreting these findings requires contextualizing both their institutional scope and their propositional nature.
The paper draws on a single national context. While these structural pressures resonate with institutional actors across the developing world, the specific regulatory mechanisms through which they operate are particular to the Philippines. Republic Act No. 12009 is a domestic statute whose procedural thresholds do not translate directly to other national jurisdictions. The Small Value Procurement pathway that makes this consortium model financially viable for Philippine state universities would need to be translated into the corresponding public finance laws governing higher education in Indonesia, Vietnam, Cambodia, or other regional partner nations.
As a structural diagnosis and institutional design proposal, this investigation establishes the regulatory and organizational groundwork required prior to capital investment. Grounded in documented statutory conditions and established international precedents, the propositional framework provides the conceptual blueprint for field deployment. Translating these principles into operational practice opens a necessary trajectory for longitudinal research, establishing an empirical agenda to document the institutional negotiations, technical adaptations, and procurement workflows as public university consortia move from regulatory modeling into live regional administration.
These structural design principles carry immediate practical and policy implications across several distinct institutional domains.
For university administrators in the Philippines, the paper provides a diagnostic framework that reframes repository abandonment as a systemic failure rather than an individual campus deficiency. When digital archives decay, the root cause is rarely staff negligence or technical illiteracy; it is an institutional model that assigns complex maintenance to isolated personnel operating under adverse environmental and fiscal conditions. This reframing carries practical value: it redirects administrative attention from individual blame toward shared investment, providing academic leaders with an institutional vocabulary to justify consortium participation to governing boards, accreditation panels, and state auditors.
For national regulators, particularly the Commission on Higher Education and the Department of Budget and Management, the paper identifies a specific gap between regulatory mandate and institutional capacity. CMO No. 22 required digital repositories without providing the means to sustain them. If CHED is serious about open access digital preservation as a component of institutional quality, the regulatory framework needs to accommodate the recurring costs of digital infrastructure within the standard budget categories available to state universities, and it needs to recognize consortium-based approaches as legitimate pathways to compliance alongside the traditional model of institution-by-institution procurement.
For international scholars studying Diamond Open Access sustainability, the paper offers a documented case of how procurement law and fiscal constraints shape infrastructure design in the Global South. The existing literature on Diamond OA, much of it produced from European and Latin American contexts, tends to assume that the primary barriers to non-commercial scholarly infrastructure are ideological, rooted in commercial publishing norms; cultural, shaped by faculty preference for prestige journals; or technical, tied to the complexity of open-source publishing software. The Philippine case shows that in many developing countries, the most immediate barriers are administrative and fiscal: not whether faculty want open access, but whether the university's accounting office can process the payment required to keep the repository online.
The structural conditions documented in this paper are not unique to the Philippines. Provincial universities across Southeast Asia, including institutions in Indonesia, Vietnam, Myanmar, Cambodia, and Laos, face similar combinations of environmental vulnerability, library understaffing, procurement rigidity, and foreign-currency dependency. Island nations in the Pacific confront the same infrastructure precarity at even greater geographic isolation. Rural institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa navigate comparable tensions between international donor-funded digital initiatives and the absence of domestic fiscal mechanisms to sustain them after the funding cycle ends. The Second Global Summit on Diamond Open Access, held in Cape Town in December 2024, explicitly acknowledged that the Diamond OA movement's credibility depends on its ability to serve institutions operating under these conditions, not merely institutions in well-resourced research systems that have already resolved the infrastructure question (Mounier and Rooryck 2024).
If Diamond Open Access is to achieve the inclusive, sovereign, collectively governed scholarly infrastructure that the UNESCO Recommendation envisions, it must be designed to operate within these conditions, not despite them, but in direct response to them. The diagnostic work of identifying structural barriers and reasoning toward institutional forms that can absorb those barriers is not a preliminary exercise to be completed before physical platform construction begins. It is the foundational intellectual labor without which any platform will reproduce the same patterns of dependency, precarity, and silent decay that characterize the current landscape.
Author: Conceptualization, Methodology, Formal Analysis, Investigation, Writing - Original Draft, Writing - Review and Editing, Project Administration.
The author declares no competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no novel statistical datasets were generated during this qualitative policy and institutional study. All statutory laws, regulatory memorandums, and institutional documentation analyzed are cited and accessible in the public domain.
Adema, Janneke, and Samuel A. Moore. 2018. "Collectivity and Collaboration: Imagining New Forms of Communality to Create Resilience in Scholar-Led Publishing." Insights: The UKSG Journal 31 (3): 1–11.
Aguado-López, Eduardo, and Arianna Becerril-García. 2019. "AmeliCA before Plan S: Latin America's Response to Open Access." The Scholarly Kitchen, March 6, 2019.
Aguado-López, Eduardo, Rosario Rogel-Salazar, Gustavo Garduño-Oropeza, and María Fernanda Zúñiga-Roca. 2003. "Redalyc: Una Alternativa a las Asimetrías en la Distribución del Conocimiento Científico." Ciencia Ergo Sum 10 (1): 11–22.
CHED (Commission on Higher Education). 2021. Memorandum Order No. 22, Series of 2021: Minimum Requirements for Libraries of Higher Education Institutions Common to All Programs. Quezon City: Commission on Higher Education.
Crosas, Mercè. 2011. "The Dataverse Network: An Open-Source Application for Sharing, Discovering and Preserving Data." D-Lib Magazine 17 (1/2).
Crossref. 2024. "Fees." Crossref. Accessed October 2025.
Gibbs, W. Wayt. 1995. "Lost Science in the Third World." Scientific American 273 (2): 92–99.
King, Gary. 2007. "An Introduction to the Dataverse Network as an Infrastructure for Data Sharing." Sociological Methods and Research 36 (2): 173–199.
Klang, Mathias. 2026. "A Final First Monday Article." Klangable, April 7, 2026.
Kunze, John A., and Emmanuelle Bermès. 2022. "The ARK Identifier Scheme." Internet Engineering Task Force, Internet-Draft.
Lagas II, Sammy, and Jonathan Isip. 2023. "Challenges to Digital Services in Philippine Academic Libraries." Philippine Journal of Librarianship and Information Studies 43 (1): 27–38.
Maxwell, John W., Erik Hanson, Leena Desai, Carmen Tiampo, Kim O'Donnell, Avvai Ketheeswaran, Melody Sun, Emma Walter, and Ellen Michelle. 2019. Mind the Gap: A Landscape Analysis of Open Source Publishing Tools and Platforms. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Mounier, Pierre, and Johan Rooryck. 2024. "Towards a Globally Distributed, Federated Infrastructure for Diamond Open Access." Discussion paper presented at the Second Global Summit on Diamond Open Access, Cape Town, South Africa, December 2024.
Packer, Abel L. 2009. "The SciELO Open Access: A Gold Way from the South." Canadian Journal of Higher Education 39 (3): 111–126.
Packer, Abel L., Mariana R. Biojone, Irati Antonio, Roberta M. Takenaka, Alberto P. García, Asael C. da Silva, and Renato T. Murasaki. 1998. "SciELO: Uma Metodologia para Publicação Eletrônica." Ciência da Informação 27 (2): 109–121.
PAGASA (Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration). 2023. Annual Tropical Cyclone Tracks. Quezon City: PAGASA.
Pooley, Jefferson. 2022. "The Case for PubPub." Elephant in the Lab, August 3, 2022.
Republic of the Philippines. 2024. Republic Act No. 12009: The New Government Procurement Act. Manila: Official Gazette.
Rich, Travis. 2020. "Alternatives to the Oligopoly in Scholarly Publishing." Presentation at the PubPub Community Summit, Cambridge, MA, February 2020.
Star, Susan Leigh, and Karen Ruhleder. 1996. "Steps Toward an Ecology of Infrastructure: Design and Access for Large Information Spaces." Information Systems Research 7 (1): 111–134.
UNESCO. 2021. UNESCO Recommendation on Open Science. Paris: United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization.
Yoon, Jiwan, Ashraf Rorissa, Nayoung Kim, and EunKyung Chung. 2024. "The Road to Sustainability: Examining Key Drivers in Open Access Diamond Journal Publishing." Learned Publishing 37 (3): e1611.